Jacob's Pickles Menu

509 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, United States
$$$ Southern restaurant (US) , American restaurant , Bar , Breakfast restaurant , Brunch restaurant , Restaurant , Sandwich shop
(7022 Reviews)
Price Range $20–30

The menu features a selection of Southern and American dishes suitable for breakfast, brunch, and casual dining throughout the day. It includes a variety of hearty entrees, sandwiches, and bar-style offerings designed for sit-down meals or relaxed gatherings.

The food items are grouped primarily into the following categories:

  • Chicken & Biscuits: This section highlights several chicken preparations served with biscuits, including BBQ Chicken, Honey Chicken, Hot Chicken Sandwich, and smothered chicken options with mushroom or sausage gravy, as well as a Southern BLT.
  • Sides: A range of accompaniments such as cheese grits, house fries, mashed potatoes with brown gravy, pickle slaw, salads, various biscuits, and additional gravy sides are available to complement main dishes.
  • Desserts: Dessert offerings include fried Oreos, bread pudding with a special variant, seasonal fresh-baked pies, and vanilla ice cream.

The menu also features signature items such as fried pickles, poutine, croque madame, meatloaf, patty melts, catfish tacos, shrimp and bacon grits, buffalo chicken mac & cheese, and southern-style specialties. Beverage options include sweet tea and classic cocktails like the Manhattan, as well as non-alcoholic choices.

This variety makes the menu suitable for breakfast and brunch occasions, as well as for lunch, dinner, or casual bar dining. Guests can expect dishes that range from lighter sides and salads to more substantial sandwiches and entrees. The menu supports both quick orders and full sit-down meals.

Appetizers

  • Bacon Steak
    US$18.00
  • Biscuit & Fixins
    US$14.00
  • Biscuit & Gravy
    US$16.00
  • Chicken Bites
    US$13.00
  • Crispy Calamari
    US$19.00
  • Deviled Eggs
    US$14.00
  • Fried Pickles
    US$15.00
  • Jumbo Pretzel
    US$16.00
  • Loaded Endive Nachos
    US$16.00
  • Matzo Ball Soup
    US$14.00
  • Okra & Chiles
    US$13.00
  • Poutine
    US$19.00
  • Salt & Vinegar Crisps
    US$16.00
  • Special Biscuit & Fixins
    US$15.00
  • Street Corn
    US$14.00
  • Tuna Tartare
    US$22.00
  • White Bean Hummus
    US$15.00

PICKLES

  • 4 Pickle Combo
    US$15.00
  • 8 Pickle Combo
    US$20.00
  • Big Dill Kosher Cukes
    US$5.00
  • Candied Red Beets
    US$5.00
  • Hot Sour Cukes
    US$5.00
  • Horseradish Cukes
    US$5.00
  • Pickled Eggs
    US$9.00
  • Bread And Butter Cukes
    US$5.00
  • Sweet & Spicy Carrots
    US$5.00
  • Thyme Jalapenos
    US$5.00

Chicken & Biscuits

  • BBQ Chicken
    US$24.00
  • Honey Chicken
    US$24.00
  • Hot Chicken Sandwich
    US$24.00
  • Mushroom Gravy Smothered Chicken
    US$24.00
  • Sausage Gravy Smothered Chicken
    US$24.00
  • Southern BLT
    US$25.00

Chicken & Toast

  • Hot Honey Chicken & Toast
    US$25.00
  • Maple Chicken & Toast
    US$25.00

Burgers

  • Smash Burger
    US$25.00
  • Duke Burger
    US$26.00
  • BBQ Bacon Smash Burger
    US$26.00
  • Lemon & Dill Salmon Burger
    US$25.00

Mac & Cheese

  • Buffalo M&C
    US$23.00
  • Classic M&C
    US$21.00
  • Lobster M&C
    US$38.00
  • Butter Pasta
    US$12.00

Mussels

  • Mussels TOWER
    US$65.00
  • White Wine Mussels
    US$31.00
  • Spicy Red Mussels
    US$31.00

Salads

  • Caesar Wrap
    US$24.00
  • Chicken Caesar Salad
    US$25.00
  • Chilled Seafood Salad
    US$28.00
  • Grilled Salmon Salad
    US$28.00
  • Portobello Mushroom Salad
    US$24.00
  • Shrimp & Endive Salad
    US$28.00
  • Waldorf Salad
    US$26.00
  • Wedge Salad
    US$25.00

Market Veggies

  • Black Eyed Peas ONLY
    US$15.00
  • Collard Greens & Black Eyed Peas
    US$15.00
  • Collards ONLY
    US$15.00
  • Grilled Asparagus
    US$14.00
  • Oyster Mushrooms
    US$16.00

Sides (table sides)

  • Cheese Grits
    US$8.00
  • House Fries
    US$15.00
  • Large House Salad
    US$12.00
  • Mashed Potatoes & Brown Gravy
    US$8.00
  • Pickle Slaw
    US$9.00
  • Side Fries
    US$9.00
  • Side Special Biscuit
    US$6.00
  • Side Biscuit
    US$5.00
  • Side Chicken
    US$12.00
  • Sausage Gravy Side
    US$6.00
  • Mushroom Gravy Side
    US$6.00
  • Side Salad
    US$8.00

Desserts

  • Fried Oreos
    US$11.00
  • Bread Pudding
    US$15.00
  • Special Bread Pudding
    US$16.00
  • Season Fresh Baked Pie
    US$16.00
  • Vanilla Ice Cream
    US$7.00

PICKLES TO GO

  • Pickle Pints
    US$6.00
  • Pickle Duo Pints
    US$10.00

$59 Catering Chicken Bites

  • CATERING Chicken Bites Sampler Platter(Hot Honey, Classic BBQ, Buffalo, And Naked)
    US$59.00
  • CATERING Hot Honey Chicken Bites
    US$59.00
  • CATERING Buffalo Chicken Bites
    US$59.00
  • CATERING Classic BBQ Chicken Bites
    US$59.00
  • CATERING Naked (Plain) Chicken Bites
    US$59.00